Baking
Christmas cookie baking supplies
Disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Details.
Nordic Ware Prism baking half sheets, 2-pack
Half-sheet pans are the workhorse for cookies and roasting.
Check price on AmazonWhat to look for: Aluminum pans with a reinforced rim, and the size in inches so you know the pan fits your oven.
Good cookies need heavy half sheet pans, parchment or silicone mats, a cookie scoop, a rolling pin, a cooling rack and a stand or hand mixer. For decorating, add cutters, piping bags, gel colors and sprinkles. Buy tins or boxes for giving.
At a glance
| Pick | Best for | Skip | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nordic Ware Prism baking half sheets, 2-pack Top pick | Anyone baking more than one tray of cookies at a time. | if you want a dishwasher-safe pan; the listing says hand wash only. Skip too if your oven is smaller than a standard range. | Check price on Amazon |
| SMARTAKE parchment paper baking sheets, 200 pcs | Bakers who do several trays and hate scrubbing. | if you only bake once a year; 200 sheets is far more than you will use. | Check price on Amazon |
| Amazon Basics silicone baking mat | Bakers who want to stop buying parchment. | for crisp-edged cookies if you prefer the browning you get on bare metal or parchment; mats can leave the bottoms paler. | Check price on Amazon |
| Cookie scoop, 2 tbsp | Cookie bakers. | if you already have a scoop; this one is a 2-tablespoon (about 1 oz) size, so the cookies come out small and uniform. | Check price on Amazon |
| Wooden rolling pin, beech wood | Anyone cutting out sugar cookies or gingerbread. | if you have a rolling pin you like; at 17.6 in this one is a plain beech roller with handles, not a specialty tool. | Check price on Amazon |
| Christmas cookie cutters, set of 9 | Cookie bakers. | if you want a large variety; this is a set of 9 shapes, and the listing says hand wash only. | Check price on Amazon |
| Cooling racks, 2-pack | Bakers who cool several trays of cookies at once. | if your counter is tiny; this is two racks, each about 14.7 x 10 in. | Check price on Amazon |
| Hamilton Beach 6-speed hand mixer | Anyone who does not own a stand mixer. | if you already own a stand mixer or only make drop cookies by hand. | Check price on Amazon |
| ChefAide silicone spatulas, 5-piece | Anyone who bakes and cooks in the same kitchen. | if you already own a good heat-resistant spatula; this is a 5-piece set. | Check price on Amazon |
| Stainless steel measuring cups and spoons set | Bakers who want measuring tools that will not warp. | if you need a 3/4-cup measure; the listing describes 1/4, 1/3, 1/2 and 1 cup measures plus six spoons. | Check price on Amazon |
| Large mixing bowls with lids, 5 qt set | Bakers who batch dough and also store it chilled. | if you are short on cupboard space; the listing says it is a nesting set but includes lids and grater attachments you may not use. | Check price on Amazon |
| Piping bags and tips set, 100 bags | Cookie decorators. | if you only ice a few cookies; this is a 124-piece kit (100 disposable bags, 16 tips and more), which is a lot for a casual decorator. | Check price on Amazon |
| Wilton edible gel food coloring set | Cookie decorators. | if anyone you bake for has a sulfite or multi-allergen sensitivity: the listing warns it contains sulfites and is made in a facility that also processes fish, milk, peanuts, sesame, shellfish, soy, tree nuts and wheat. | Check price on Amazon |
| Christmas sprinkles baking variety | Cookie decorators. | if you want only red and green nonpareils; this is a six-cell mix of jimmies, nonpareils, tree shapes, confetti and sugar crystals. | Check price on Amazon |
| Christmas cookie boxes for gift giving, 12 | Cookie givers. | if you need the box count to be exact: the listing title says 12 boxes but a bullet says 24, so check the live page before you plan around it. These are kraft paper boxes, not reusable tins. | Check price on Amazon |
Cookie season rewards organization. If you are making three kinds in one afternoon, you need pans that rotate through the oven, parchment so nothing sticks and a scoop so every cookie is the same size.
For decorated sugar cookies, you also need a rolling surface, cutters and a way to ice neatly.
How to choose
- Heavy half sheet pans. They heat evenly and do not warp.
- Parchment or silicone mats. They stop sticking and make cleanup trivial.
- A scoop. Uniform dough balls bake evenly.
- A rack and storage. Cooling racks and tins keep the cookies fresh and ready to give.
Chill dough before baking for neater shapes, and bake one sheet at a time for the most even results.
All the picks
-
Nordic Ware Prism baking half sheets, 2-packOur pick
Half-sheet pans are the workhorse for cookies and roasting.
- Listing says:
- Aluminum; 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 in (L x W x H); 1.6 pounds; 2 Count
- Look for:
- Aluminum pans with a reinforced rim, and the size in inches so you know the pan fits your oven.
- Best for:
- Anyone baking more than one tray of cookies at a time.
- Skip:
- if you want a dishwasher-safe pan; the listing says hand wash only. Skip too if your oven is smaller than a standard range.
-
SMARTAKE parchment paper baking sheets, 200 pcs
Pre-cut parchment lines pans.
- Listing says:
- Wood Pulp; 12 x 16 in (L x W); 0.23 kg; 200 Count
- Best for:
- Bakers who do several trays and hate scrubbing.
- Skip:
- if you only bake once a year; 200 sheets is far more than you will use.
-
Amazon Basics silicone baking mat
A silicone mat keeps cookies from sticking.
- Listing says:
- Silicone; 16.5 x 11.6 in (L x W); 0.23 kg; 2 Count
- Look for:
- A mat sized to your pan; at 16.5 x 11.6 in this one is made for a half sheet like the pan above.
- Best for:
- Bakers who want to stop buying parchment.
- Skip:
- for crisp-edged cookies if you prefer the browning you get on bare metal or parchment; mats can leave the bottoms paler.
-
Cookie scoop, 2 tbsp
A scoop makes cookies the same size.
- Listing says:
- Stainless Steel; 8.5 x 2.75 in (L x W); 0.19 kg
- Best for:
- Cookie bakers.
- Skip:
- if you already have a scoop; this one is a 2-tablespoon (about 1 oz) size, so the cookies come out small and uniform.
-
Wooden rolling pin, beech wood
A wooden pin rolls out dough evenly.
- Listing says:
- Beech Wood; 18 x 2.5 in (L x W)
- Best for:
- Anyone cutting out sugar cookies or gingerbread.
- Skip:
- if you have a rolling pin you like; at 17.6 in this one is a plain beech roller with handles, not a specialty tool.
-
Christmas cookie cutters, set of 9
A set of cutters shapes the classics.
- Listing says:
- Stainless Steel; 9 Count; hand wash only
- Look for:
- Stainless steel with a rolled top edge to protect your hand, and a set that includes the shapes you will use (gingerbread man, tree, star).
- Best for:
- Cookie bakers.
- Skip:
- if you want a large variety; this is a set of 9 shapes, and the listing says hand wash only.
-
Cooling racks, 2-pack
Racks cool cookies evenly.
- Listing says:
- 14.68 x 10 x 0.67 in; 14.9 ounces
- Best for:
- Bakers who cool several trays of cookies at once.
- Skip:
- if your counter is tiny; this is two racks, each about 14.7 x 10 in.
-
Hamilton Beach 6-speed hand mixer
A hand mixer handles cookie dough and whipped cream.
- Listing says:
- Plastic, Stainless Steel; 8.3 x 5.7 x 9.2 in (D x W x H); 1.3 kg
- Look for:
- Beaters and a whisk that are dishwasher safe, a bowl rest, and a case so attachments do not go missing.
- Best for:
- Anyone who does not own a stand mixer.
- Skip:
- if you already own a stand mixer or only make drop cookies by hand.
-
ChefAide silicone spatulas, 5-piece
Spatulas scrape the bowl clean.
- Listing says:
- Silicone; 5 Count
- Best for:
- Anyone who bakes and cooks in the same kitchen.
- Skip:
- if you already own a good heat-resistant spatula; this is a 5-piece set.
-
Stainless steel measuring cups and spoons set
A sturdy set measures accurately.
- Listing says:
- Stainless Steel; 3.5 x 2.9 x 5.5 in; 12.8 ounces
- Look for:
- Engraved size marks and a set that includes every measure your recipes call for.
- Best for:
- Bakers who want measuring tools that will not warp.
- Skip:
- if you need a 3/4-cup measure; the listing describes 1/4, 1/3, 1/2 and 1 cup measures plus six spoons.
-
Large mixing bowls with lids, 5 qt set
A nested set of bowls covers the work.
- Listing says:
- stainless steel; five bowls from 1.5 to 5 qt with lids and non-slip silicone bases; dishwasher safe; includes three grater attachments
- Best for:
- Bakers who batch dough and also store it chilled.
- Skip:
- if you are short on cupboard space; the listing says it is a nesting set but includes lids and grater attachments you may not use.
-
Piping bags and tips set, 100 bags
Piping bags make decorating cookies easy.
- Listing says:
- 124-piece kit: 100 disposable piping bags (11.8 in), 16 stainless steel tips, 1 reusable pastry bag, cake scrapers and couplers
- Best for:
- Cookie decorators.
- Skip:
- if you only ice a few cookies; this is a 124-piece kit (100 disposable bags, 16 tips and more), which is a lot for a casual decorator.
-
Wilton edible gel food coloring set
Gel colors make bright icing.
- Listing says:
- 12 gel colors (including red, green, brown, black, burgundy, violet, teal, pink and yellows); 18.14 g; all ages
- Look for:
- A gel (not liquid) set, so the icing does not thin out; the listing says the color deepens over time.
- Best for:
- Cookie decorators.
- Skip:
- if anyone you bake for has a sulfite or multi-allergen sensitivity: the listing warns it contains sulfites and is made in a facility that also processes fish, milk, peanuts, sesame, shellfish, soy, tree nuts and wheat.
-
Christmas sprinkles baking variety
A set of sprinkles finishes cookies.
- Listing says:
- 6.45 oz in a resealable six-cell container: jimmies, nonpareils, tree shapes, holiday confetti, red and green sugar crystals
- Best for:
- Cookie decorators.
- Skip:
- if you want only red and green nonpareils; this is a six-cell mix of jimmies, nonpareils, tree shapes, confetti and sugar crystals.
-
Christmas cookie boxes for gift giving, 12
Boxes let you give cookies as gifts.
- Listing says:
- kraft paper bakery boxes with window; 8.75 x 5.75 x 2.75 in; listing title says 12 pieces (one bullet says 24); three Christmas designs
- Best for:
- Cookie givers.
- Skip:
- if you need the box count to be exact: the listing title says 12 boxes but a bullet says 24, so check the live page before you plan around it. These are kraft paper boxes, not reusable tins.
What the listings say, and how the picks fit together
The specs above are quoted from each product’s own Amazon listing, opened on October 25, 2026. Listings change, so check the live page for size, count and material before you order. A few things that stood out when we put them side by side:
- The pan, mat and parchment line up. The Nordic Ware half sheets list 17.9 x 12.9 in. The silicone mat is 16.5 x 11.6 in and the parchment is 12 x 16 in, so both fit inside the pan. The parchment leaves a margin at the long ends, which is fine for cookies but not for lining a roasting tray to the edges.
- Pick one, not both, of mat and parchment. The mat is reusable; the parchment is a 200-sheet box. Use parchment for the occasional bake and the mat if you bake often.
- The cooling racks fit inside the pan. Two racks of about 14.7 x 10 in sit within a half sheet, so you can cool cookies on the rack without moving them off the tray.
- Check allergens before you decorate for guests. The gel colors list sulfites and a multi-allergen facility, which matters for icing you give away.
- This is a supplies guide, not a recipe. If you bake one batch a year, the pan, parchment and a scoop are enough; the rest is for people who decorate cookies.
What to skip
- Novelty cutters with thin details. They are hard to release.
- Dark nonstick pans for pale cookies, which brown too fast.
- Huge sprinkle assortments you will not use.
- A new mixer just for cookies. A hand mixer is enough.
For giving, see neighbor gifts for the holidays and gift wrapping supplies. For the cook on your list, try gifts for cooks. If the cookies are for a party with a set count and a label on each tin, use how to host a cookie exchange. If the cookies are going in the mail, how to mail cookies has the packing steps and which cookies survive the trip.
Questions people ask
What baking tools do I need for cookies?
Half sheet pans, parchment or silicone mats, a scoop, a rolling pin, cooling racks and a mixer cover most recipes. Add cutters and icing supplies for decorated cookies.
How do I keep cookies from spreading?
Chill the dough, use cool pans and weigh your ingredients. Parchment lets cookies hold their shape better than a greased pan.
How should I store cookies for gifts?
Cool completely, then layer them in a tin or box with parchment between layers. Most cookies keep well for several days; label any with nuts.
Email me this gift list
Save this guide’s address with your email. This stores the request. Nothing is sent from this form.
We'll only use your email for this request. Privacy.
Save an occasion reminder request
Store a birthday, anniversary, or holiday date with your email and this guide. This stores the request. A reminder is not sent from this form.
We'll only use your email for this request. Privacy.