Secret Santa
Secret Santa gifts under $25
Disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Details.
PILOT G2 Premium gel pens, assorted inks
Smooth-writing gel pens in a mixed pack are used up quickly and rarely bought for oneself.
Check price on AmazonFor a Secret Santa limit of $25 or less (including $15 groups) choose small, unscented-or-classic, useful items that most people accept: good pens, hand cream, tea, coasters, a candle or a tape measure. Avoid anything personal, edible with allergens or joke-based.
At a glance
Secret Santa is a different game from white elephant: you know exactly who will get your gift, you know they will see it right away, and you probably know very little about them. The goal is something kind, useful and impossible to misread.
Prices move daily, so treat the budget as a target and check the live price on Amazon before you buy. These are small items chosen to fit comfortably inside a $25 limit, including groups that cap at $15.
How to choose
- Start with the desk or the kitchen. Pens, notes and coasters are neutral and used.
- Use a theme. A small mug-and-cocoa pair or a bundled “winter hand kit” looks more thoughtful than one item.
- Check dietary needs. If you choose food, ask the organizer for allergies.
- Read the rules. Some groups ask for a wish list or ban consumables.
Limit higher than $25? The ideas in gifts under $50 work for Secret Santa too. Want something more playful? That’s white elephant territory.
All the picks
-
PILOT G2 Premium gel pens, assorted inksOur pick
Smooth-writing gel pens in a mixed pack are used up quickly and rarely bought for oneself.
- Best for:
- Students, planners and teachers.
- Skip:
- for people who write only on screens.
-
Mr. Pen sticky notes set, 410 pack
A mixed pack of sticky notes covers study guides and reminders.
- Look for:
- A pack with ruled and blank notes.
-
Neutrogena Norwegian Formula hand cream
A fragrance-free hand cream is a staple for dry winter hands.
- Best for:
- Anyone with dry hands.
-
Yogi Soothing Caramel Bedtime tea
A caffeine-free bedtime tea suits a winter evening.
- Best for:
- Tea drinkers.
-
Burt's Bees moisturizing lip balm, 4-pack
A four-pack of lip balm is used in every coat.
-
Zebra F-701 stainless steel pen
A steel pen is a small, solid tool that men carry.
-
Carmex classic lip balm, 3-pack
Carmex is the lip balm in every pocket.
-
CRAFTSMAN 25-ft tape measure
A tape measure disappears from every house; a new one is always welcome.
- Best for:
- Anyone who builds.
-
Candy cane peppermint stirring spoons, 12-set
Peppermint spoons turn a mug of hot chocolate into a small treat and are easy to tuck into a card.
- Look for:
- Individually wrapped spoons and a seal.
- Best for:
- Cocoa fans and gift-basket builders.
-
Acacia wood coasters with holder
A set of absorbent wood coasters saves a table and looks nice on a coffee table.
- Look for:
- A holder, a flat base and absorbent material.
- Best for:
- New home owners and hosts.
-
Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day soy candle, Lavender
A small, nicely scented soy candle is a safe, thoughtful small gift.
- Look for:
- A lid and a scent you know the person likes.
- Best for:
- Hosts, teachers and neighbors.
- Skip:
- if they dislike lavender; choose a different scent.
-
OXO Good Grips small silicone flexible turner
A flexible nonstick-safe turner is what people reach for every day for eggs and pancakes.
- Look for:
- Heat-resistant silicone and a thin, flexible edge.
- Best for:
- Anyone who cooks on nonstick pans.
- Skip:
- if they already own a drawer of spatulas.
What to skip
- Anything intimate: clothing, grooming products and body care.
- Gag gifts about age, weight or relationship status.
- Alcohol. It is banned in many workplaces and excludes non-drinkers.
- Overly strong scents.
For more office ideas, see gifts for coworkers and our original Secret Santa gifts for coworkers guide.
Questions people ask
What is a good Secret Santa gift under $25?
Pens, a notebook, hand cream, tea or a small candle: nothing personal and nothing that needs a size. A short handwritten note makes a small gift feel considered.
What if our Secret Santa limit is $15 or $50?
With a $15 limit choose from the smallest items here (pens, sticky notes, lip balm, cocoa spoons) and check the live price. With a $50 limit our gifts-under-50 guide has larger ideas that are still neutral for a name you barely know; the same rules apply: nothing personal, nothing that needs a size.
How do I shop for someone I barely know?
Choose neutral items that suit a desk or a kitchen, and avoid personal care and humor. If possible, ask the organizer or a colleague about hobbies or dietary needs.
Can I give food as a Secret Santa gift?
Yes, if you check allergies and choose sealed, widely liked items such as tea or cocoa. Avoid nuts unless you know the recipient is fine with them.
Email me this gift list
Save this guide’s address with your email. This stores the request. Nothing is sent from this form.
We'll only use your email for this request. Privacy.
Save an occasion reminder request
Store a birthday, anniversary, or holiday date with your email and this guide. This stores the request. A reminder is not sent from this form.
We'll only use your email for this request. Privacy.